Mentimeter entertains audiences. Chooseday produces decisions your team can act on.
Mentimeter is built around a presenter running a session with an audience present simultaneously. For a conference keynote or a company all-hands where everyone is on the same call, that model works brilliantly. But most teams making meaningful decisions aren’t in the same room, or even the same timezone. The requirement to gather everyone live is a meaningful constraint that Mentimeter was never designed to solve.
And even when you can get everyone together, the live-results format creates anchoring bias. Research on social influence in voting is consistent: when people can see how others have voted, subsequent votes skew toward the early results. A vote taken under those conditions isn’t measuring genuine individual preferences, it’s measuring the group’s reaction to the first few responses. For a team vote that actually needs to reflect what people think, that’s a significant problem.
Mentimeter also has no persistent decision record. Results exist within a presentation session, and while you can export a report, there’s no native decision archive where your team can look back and see what was decided, when, and by what margin. For teams that need accountability and traceability around their decisions, this gap matters.
Chooseday is async by default. You create a decision, add your options with as much context as each needs, set a deadline, and share a link. Your team votes whenever they’re online, no synchronous session, no presenter, no time-zone coordination. The results stay hidden until the deadline passes, so every voter makes an independent choice without seeing what others have done.
Anonymous voting is available on Chooseday’s free plan, not as a premium add-on. For sensitive decisions around team structure, compensation, or performance, anonymity isn’t optional: it’s the only way to get honest input. When the vote closes, Chooseday declares the winner automatically and saves the decision, including the vote breakdown, to a permanent archive that your team can reference indefinitely.
Who should use Chooseday instead of Mentimeter: distributed teams who can’t gather live for every decision; teams making sensitive choices where live visible results create social pressure; any situation where you need a permanent record of what was decided and why. Mentimeter excels at audience engagement during presentations, Chooseday excels at getting genuine, accountable decisions made without a room.
The honest comparison
The problems Chooseday was built to solve
Chooseday is async first. Share a link, set a deadline. Team members vote whenever they're online, across any timezone. No synchronous session required.
Chooseday keeps results hidden until the vote closes. Every voter has the same unbiased view. The result reflects genuine individual preferences, not groupthink.
Every Chooseday decision is permanently archived, with the original options, the vote breakdown, and the declared winner. Revisit any decision months later.
Every feature that matters, compared
We used Mentimeter for team votes during all-hands meetings, but decisions made in a room with live results are just mob rule. Chooseday changed that, async, anonymous, and the result actually stands.
Mentimeter is great for keeping a conference audience awake. It's useless for actual team decision-making. Chooseday is what we use for anything real.
Everything you need to know
Join 2,400+ teams already using Chooseday. Free forever for small teams.