Mentimeter turns presentations into polls. Chooseday turns team input into actual decisions, with context, rankings, and a clear winner every time.
Mentimeter was built for live presentations. It is excellent at what it does, putting a poll on a big screen while an audience votes from their phones. But that live-session model is also its fundamental constraint. If your team is not all in the same room at the same time, Mentimeter does not work for you. And even when they are, results shown in real time during a live session introduce anchoring bias: people see how others voted and adjust their answers accordingly. The result is consensus shaped by the room, not genuine individual opinion.
Teams searching for a Mentimeter alternative are usually dealing with one of three problems: their team is distributed across time zones and a live session is impractical, they want anonymous voting on a free plan rather than a paid tier, or they need decisions to be recorded with context rather than disappearing after the session ends. Mentimeter does not solve any of these problems natively.
The most important question is whether you need live polling or async team decisions. If your polls happen in a meeting room with everyone present, Mentimeter may serve you fine. But if you need people to vote on their own time, before a meeting, across departments, or with teammates in different time zones, you need a tool built for async. Look for: deadline-based voting so the poll closes automatically, anonymous voting included at no extra cost, a way to give each option context and description so voters are informed, and a decision record that persists after the vote closes. Ranked choice support is also worth checking if your decisions involve more than two options.
Chooseday is purpose-built for exactly the use case Mentimeter cannot handle: async team decisions where the result needs to be trusted, recorded, and actionable. You set a deadline, teammates vote whenever they are online, and results are hidden until the vote closes, eliminating the anchoring bias that plagues live sessions. Anonymous voting is included on the free plan, not gated behind a paid tier. Every decision is stored permanently with its options, vote breakdown, and declared winner, so you have a searchable record of what your team decided and why. If you are running team polls, planning sessions, or group decisions and do not need a live presentation screen, Chooseday is the more appropriate tool.
The honest comparison
The problems Chooseday was built to solve
Chooseday structures every decision with options, context, and a declared winner. It's not just a poll, it's a decision record your team can refer back to.
Chooseday has no live session requirement. Create a decision, set a deadline, and your team votes whenever works for them, across timezones.
Every Chooseday decision is logged, the options, who voted, the result, and any notes. Your decision history is searchable and permanent.
Every feature that matters, compared
We were using Menti for quarterly planning but it required a live meeting. Chooseday let us run the same vote async and get honest answers without the politics.
The anonymous mode changed everything. People started voting for what they actually believed, not what they thought was the right answer to give in front of the team.
Everything you need to know
Join 2,400+ teams already using Chooseday. Free forever for small teams.